The stoning law, wan’ni, and sharia implementations
Image source: themuslimwoman.org
by Jennie S. Bev
Bylaws in Aceh for stoning adulterers to death and 100 lashes for premarital sex should be nullified as they are not merely against human rights and unconstitutional, but perpetuate the myth of inequality and overindulge in the over-virtuousness of Islam and sharia law.
Failure to nullify them will have grave consequences in which not only will pluralism be threatened but it will engender an age of distrust and Indonesia will be thrust back into the Dark Ages.
The first argument comes from the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the 1990 Cairo Declaration on Human Rights in Islam, in which all human beings have the right to a dignified life.
The second argument comes from Indonesia’s national laws, which include ratifications of international human rights conventions, overriding the special autonomy region’s bylaws.
The third argument comes from questioning the definition of “sharia” laws themselves: which ones are Islamic and which ones are customary. This article tries to reach an understanding of the third argument.
Fiqh or jurisprudence in Islam is one of the most complicated studies of all Islamic-related schools. It is also the most powerful, because those who understand them are likely to be listened to seriously by society.
In the past, sharia had been seen as a set of rules, in which was the evolution of legal reasoning, this paradigm is now acknowledged as a set of social practices and a set of ever-evolving interpretive processes.
This, however, hasn’t been uniformly understood, which has caused there to be various interpretations, particularly among the less academic clerics who interpret sharia as “written in stone because God tells us so.”
Certain principles, however, are indeed absolute, such as God as the source of utmost mercy and compassion. This principle alone contradicts the so-called “sharia law” implementation, such as mutilating limbs, lashing, and stoning to death.
That grave wrongdoings require draconian consequences may sound fair, but it comes with a huge logical fallacy: God has been belittled as a human being and God’s reasoning has been reduced to a petty human being’s.
An example of feudal practice that has been considered as “Islamic” is the tradition of wan’ni in Pakistan, in which female family members of a murderer are given away to the victim’s family as a form of restitution.
Islamic scholars have agreed that the practice of wan’ni is indeed unIslamic as it shifted the notion of “sin” to another individual, which is both unjust and unfair regardless of one’s gender.
The socialization of wan’ni as a form of gender-related human rights violation and not as a part of Islamic law has been attributed to Rubina Bhatti, who was nominated for the 2005 Nobel Peace Prize.
Indonesia recognizes national law, adat law, and Islamic law, and such acknowledgement creates an environment of possible conflicts of laws, if both the enactment and the implementation are not clearly regulated.
At this point, many legal scholars argue that Aceh is a special autonomy region, which provides it with legal privileges.
While this argument makes some sense, we must see Indonesia as a whole picture and the puzzles of legal implications and social consequences at various levels must be taken into account.
So far, the tendency has been the implementation of draconian measures, which include stoning to death and mutilating of limbs, attributed to so-called “Islamic laws.”
Whether this assumption is valid or not requires an in-depth investigation of historical, social, customary, and legal developments.
Here, Islam is more than a religion; it is a framework upon which elements of an evolving civilization are based. And as a framework, its elements keep evolving as well. Nothing is written in stone, only God is ever-present and the most compassionate.
Thus, adopting draconian inhumane measures for wrongdoings in various communities, such as stoning to death, giving away female family members as a restitution of murder, lashing, and mutilating limbs must not be transplanted to Indonesia simply because they have been labeled “sharia” by a few past clerics who resided in various Arab countries.
It is, indeed, a grave fallacy to reduce the human reasoning capacity to such an oversimplification and reversed dynamic.
While an Islamic society is based on virtue, which is very noble, it is also expected that critical thinking is given a strong emphasis.
After all, modernity is not the antonym of nobility and decency, so one does not contradict the other. Modernity occupies specific parts of the temporal domain while decency occupies timelessness.
Abid Ullah Jan, a thinker of the Independent Center for Strategic Studies and Analyses in Canada said that both Muslims and non-Muslims are engaged in jihad (struggle), qital (war), and ijtihad (struggle to reach right conclusion), but any pseudo-Islamic state that indulges in fiqh alone is likely to progress to be as the corrupt Taliban.
We certainly do not want Aceh to taint pluralistic Indonesia, the beacon of the world’s moderate Muslims.[]
_____
The writer is an Indonesian-born author and columnist based in Northern California. She can be found at JennieSBev.com. This article was published by the Jakarta Post.
You actually make it appear really easy along with your presentation but I to find this topic to be really one thing that I think I might by no means understand. It seems too complicated and extremely large for me. I am taking a look forward on your next submit, I’ll try to get the hold of it!
Consumer Electronics Review
22 Apr 11 at 6:32 pm
I’ll immediately grab your rss as I can not find your email subscription link or e-newsletter service. Do you have any? Kindly let me know so that I could subscribe. Thanks.
Buy Weber Grills On Sale
12 Jul 11 at 4:31 pm
dsa321123asd
dsa321
1 Aug 11 at 9:33 am
I recently started reading your post and after few seconds, I discovered it quite interesting. I read your mostly all of the posts. Nice posts, thanks a ton for sharing the posts operating.
Culver City Electrical
17 Aug 11 at 6:36 pm
Wow, there’s really a lot to know around and another could get overwhelmed but when you know the best places to focus, this is all worth your time. Enjoyed this page! Huntington Park Electrical
Huntington Park Electrical
17 Aug 11 at 7:43 pm
Hi,After looking at this post I favor it quite definitely we appreciate you in your effort. I must declare that it is quite good and informative. Thanks. Saratoga Plumbing
Saratoga Plumbing
17 Aug 11 at 8:40 pm
Being a Newbie, My business is always searching online for articles which can help me. Thank you so much
Pacoima Electrical
24 Aug 11 at 10:23 pm
I cant wait to see more by you. This is really an excellent blog. Pest Control National City
Pest Control National City
28 Aug 11 at 6:37 am
We’re greatly happy with the contents you’ve mentioned. I enjoyed every little bit some of it. Its content has truly information. I would like to i appreciate you for this informative read; I really appreciate sharing this brilliant.
Shawnee KS Plumbing
3 Sep 11 at 3:48 am
What on earth is captcha code?, pls provide me captcha code codes or plugin, Thanks beforehand.
Leawood Plumbing
3 Sep 11 at 4:34 am
I’m very much satisfied with the contents you may have mentioned. Needed saying thanks to you for this great article. I uncovered this is an informational message and interesting, and so i imagine that is rather helpful and knowledgeable for me personally. I have to thanks for the efforts they have built to write this good article. If at all possible, as you gain expertise, are you able to updating your site with an increase of information? It is very a good choice for me.
Plumbing Lee's Summit
3 Sep 11 at 4:39 am
We’re significantly pleased with the contents you could have mentioned. I enjoyed every small amount part of it. Its content has truly information. I wish to appreciate this informative read; I truly appreciate sharing this great.
Henderson Plumbing
3 Sep 11 at 5:09 am
Nice Information! Personally, i really appreciate your article. It is a great website. I am going to guarantee that I stop back again!.
Malibu Plumbing
3 Sep 11 at 5:57 am
Many thanks for making the effort to go about this, I find myself strongly concerning this and love learning much more about this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, might you mind updating your blog with an increase of information? It’s very great for me.
Plumbing Ross
3 Sep 11 at 11:10 pm
It really is this type of interesting thing possessing this post of yours. I had been interested with all the topic plus the flow on the story. Carry on the truly amazing work.
Vista Electrician
4 Sep 11 at 9:46 pm
Your blog post is STELLAR! After all, Ive never been so entertained by anything inside my life! After all, how have you locate something matches your thing of writing so well? Im really happy I started looking over this today. You need an acquaintance within me without a doubt!
La Mirada Electrician
4 Sep 11 at 11:55 pm
Great stuff from you, man. I’ve read your stuff before and you’re just too awesome. I love what you’ve came, love what you’re saying and the way you say it. You’re making it entertaining and you still have the ability to ensure that is stays smart. I can’t wait you just read more from you. This really is an incredible blog.
Jacksonville Electrical
7 Sep 11 at 4:46 pm
Amazing blog and incredibly interesting things came! I definitely learned a lot from examining several of your earlier posts at the same time and thought i would drop a investigate this place!
Milwaukee Electrical
7 Sep 11 at 5:44 pm
Good post, I do believe you’ll write good post and I helps keep see more post from a blog.
Oklahoma City Electrical
7 Sep 11 at 6:34 pm
I needed saying thanks to you with this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little it We have you bookmarked to think about new items you post.
Tucson Electrical
7 Sep 11 at 7:19 pm
Hi there! The blog is totally fantastic. A whole lot information and inspiration, as both versions young people need. Thanks.
Nashville Plumbing
7 Sep 11 at 11:52 pm
The blog was absolutely fantastic! Wide range of great information which may be useful when you are some or the other way. Keep updating the blog,anticipating for additional contents…Great job, continue the good work..
Plumbing Atlanta
8 Sep 11 at 12:08 am
Thanks for spending some time to debate this, I am strongly regarding it and love learning more on this topic. When possible, just like you gain expertise, can you mind updating your website to comprehend information? This can be very helpful for me.
Albuquerque Plumbing
8 Sep 11 at 1:50 am
Hey, everyone! I don’t mean to hijack this convo, but has anyone done business with Comcast 817 N Main St Jacksonville FL 32202 (904) 562-2093? I’m thinking about using them for their debt consolidation services, but unfortunately have experienced some massive frustrations with debt consolidation companies in past times. Thanks!
Antonietta Tobiasson
5 Oct 11 at 5:30 pm
I would like to thanks for the efforts you cash in on in some recoverable format this informative article. I’m hoping exactly the same best product on your part in the foreseeable future also.
Beverly Hills Plumbing
5 Oct 11 at 6:08 pm
How’s it goin’, everyone! I have no intentions of hijacking this conversation, but has anyone done business with Comcast Service Center 240 Sip, Avenue Jersey City NJ, 07306 (201) 254-7867? I’m thinking about using them for their debt consolidation services, but unfortunately have had some serious disappointments with debt consolidation agencies in past times. Thanks!
Derek Petrowski
5 Oct 11 at 10:04 pm
Despite the fact that I really enjoy the conversation happening here… I do have a very quick dilemma that I need to have resolved ahead of the day’s end. I am getting ready to do business with Comcast 2-118 NE 1st St Fort Lauderdale FL (954) 213-6988, but am a little hesitant. I’ve had some debt consolidation businesses prior to now not treat me well, so I prefer to stay clear of that through getting a few other consumers ideas on them.
Sara Berkheimer
6 Oct 11 at 10:43 pm
|I don’t regularly interrupt amazing chats like this with questions, but I in dire need of help from anyone who is happy to lend me a hand. I’m considering employing Comcast 1500 Grant St Denver CO 80203 (720) 377-0491, and I was wondering if anyone here has used them in the past. I am hunting for both the negative and positive issues with their business. Please get back to me in a timely manner for this is extremely important.Thank you.|
Dessie Sabine
6 Oct 11 at 10:43 pm
naturally like your website but you have to check the spelling on several of your posts. Many of them are rife with spelling problems and I find it very troublesome to tell the truth nevertheless I’ll surely come back again.
Learn How To Get Rid Of Cellulite
10 Oct 11 at 6:30 pm
|I don’t regularly interrupt impressive convos such as this with inquiries, but I really need the help of whoever happy to lend me a hand. I’m conducting some research employing Comcast 3103 E Grant Ave Fresno CA, 93702 (559) 354-9118 and I wanted to ask if anyone here has employed them in the past. I am interested in both the bad and good areas of their business. Please get back to me as fast as possible for this is very important.Thanks a lot.
Margaretta Clusky
11 Oct 11 at 4:54 pm
First of all i would like to thanks for the good and informative entry.Need to admit that I never learned about this data We’ve noticed many new facts for me personally. Bless you for sharing this useful and attractive information and i also are going to be expecting other interesting posts from you inside nearest future.keep it up. San Diego Heating
San Diego Heating
3 Dec 11 at 7:40 pm
Hi there, You have performed an excellent job. I¡¦ll certainly digg it and personally recommend to my friends. I am sure they’ll be benefited from this website.
Sergio
8 Jan 12 at 5:25 am
I tend not to leave a leave a response, however I read a few of the remarks here %BLOGTITLE%. I do have a couple of questions for you if it’s okay. Could it be simply me or do a few of these remarks appear as if they are coming from brain dead individuals?
And, if you are posting at additional online social sites, I would like to follow everything new you have to post. Could you post a list of all of your social sites like your linkedin profile, Facebook page or twitter feed?
blogger wordpress
10 Feb 12 at 4:27 pm
Thanks for the Information, interesting useful Post. Maintain good work!!
Pacheco Ca Plumbing
2 Mar 12 at 7:35 pm
I will right away clutch your rss as I can not to find your email subscription link or e-newsletter service. Do you have any? Please allow me recognise so that I could subscribe. Thanks.
repair service
28 Jul 12 at 9:34 pm
I seldom leave comments, but i did some searching
And, if you are posting on additional online sites, I would like to follow everything fresh you have to post. Would you make a list of every one of all your shared pages like your twitter feed, Facebook page or linkedin profile?
and wound up here The stoning law, wan’ni, and sharia implementations at Overseas Think
Tank for Indonesia. And I do have a couple of questions for you if
it’s allright. Is it only me or does it look like a few of the responses look like they are left by brain dead folks?
proba
28 Apr 13 at 12:16 am